From Crickets to Clicks: Why Your Social Posts Aren’t Working—And How to Fix Them

Why No One’s Clicking: It’s Not You—It’s Your Strategy

Man holsing a cell phone with Like and Heart emojis scattered surrounding the phone.

We’ve all been there:
You spend time crafting the perfect post—maybe even throw in a trending sound or a clever caption—and then…

Nothing.

Crickets.

No likes, no comments, no clicks.


Here’s the thing: It’s not that your content is bad. But if it’s not connecting, it’s not converting—and we’re here to fix that.

Let’s break down the most common reasons your social posts might be falling flat—and, more importantly, how to turn those crickets into clicks.


1. You’re Talking at Your Audience, Not to Them

A lot of content reads more like a billboard than a conversation.
People scroll past sales pitches—but they stop for real talk, stories, and helpful insights.

Fix it:
   Start your posts like you're answering a question from a real person. Be curious. Be helpful. And don’t be afraid to show your personality.

Instead of: “We offer expert bookkeeping services.”
Try: “Tired of feeling lost during tax season? Here’s how we help small business owners make sense of their books—without the jargon.”

2. You’re Posting Without a Plan

If your content feels random, your audience will scroll right past it.
Strategy always beats spontaneity.

Fix it:
   Use a content calendar to map out posts that align with your goals and speak to your audience’s real needs.
Themes like:

  • FAQs you’re always answering
  • Behind-the-scenes looks
  • Client wins and case studies
  • Quick tips and industry insights

That consistency builds trust and momentum.


3. It’s Not Clear What You Want People to Do

Great content should always have a job—whether it’s to educate, engage, or drive action.
But if your post ends without a clear next step, people won’t take one.

Fix it:
   Always include a call to action (CTA), even if it’s as simple as:

  • “Comment below if this sounds like you.”
  • “Save this for later.”
  • “Want help with this? DM us and let’s talk.”

Clarity = clicks.


4. You’re Prioritizing Perfection Over Connection

Yes, aesthetic is important. But your audience doesn’t need perfection—they need value.

Fix it:
   Don’t wait for perfect lighting or the exact right words.
   Done is better than perfect. Real is better than polished.
   And showing up consistently will beat one perfect post every time.


5. You're Ignoring What’s Already Working

Sometimes the best insights are right under your nose. If you’ve had posts that performed well in the past—double down on what clicked.

Fix it:
   Review your analytics and ask:

  • What posts got saves, shares, or replies?
  • What topics got people talking?
  • What formats (video, carousels, stories) worked best?

Repeat, remix, and repurpose. You don’t need to start from scratch every time.


Final Thoughts:

Your content can work harder for you—you just need a strategy that connects.

💡 The good news? You don’t have to do it alone.
At NEKO, we help small businesses turn scattered content into strategic conversations that convert.

📩 Ready to go from crickets to clicks? Let’s talk!

Let's Get Those Clicks
A bunch of red balloons with the word sale on them
By Blog Owner July 9, 2025
Boost your summer sale or pop-up with a promo page, countdown timer, event schema, and email support. Make your website part of the team!
A person is holding a cell phone with social media icons on the screen
By Blog Owner July 1, 2025
Discover what’s trending on social media in 2025. Plus, explore strategy sessions and content calendar services from Northeast Kingdom Online!
Canned spam emails with Northeast Kingdom Online
June 30, 2025
Learn how we know those "guest post services" emails are spam, how they can hurt your SEO, and what to do instead to build real website credibility.
A person holding up a phone in front of a TV, screensharing to the TV, showing social media posts.
June 24, 2025
Not sure how often to post on social media or your blog? This guide breaks down realistic, consistent content strategies for small business owners who want results—without the burnout.
Computer with abstract image of buildings, angled towards the sky, reading
June 17, 2025
Using a website theme? Learn how small businesses in Vermont can personalize it with custom colors, fonts, imagery, and messaging, so your site stands out, not blends in.
A laptop at a desk setting, with the LinkedIn logo on the screen.
June 10, 2025
LinkedIn isn’t just for job seekers. Discover how Vermont small businesses and service providers can use it to build trust, grow local networks, and share their expertise effectively.
A red, neon, 404 sign, signifying an error.
June 4, 2025
Not sure if your website is still working for your business? Discover 6 common signs it's time for a redesign, like outdated visuals, slow speed, or unclear messaging, and what to do next.
A wall that is covered with sticky notes is a disorganized mess.
May 21, 2025
Dreaming of viral content and sleek branding? The real secret to a strong digital presence starts with a content calendar. Discover how strategic planning, consistency, and simple content themes can transform your online strategy—no stress spirals required.
Letter tiles spelling out the word, blog, on a desk.
May 21, 2025
Wondering if blogging is still worth it? Spoiler: it is. In this post, we break down exactly why blogging remains a powerful tool for growing your business—boosting visibility, building trust, and supporting your entire content strategy. You’ll also get simple blog topic ideas to help you get started with ease.
A person researching frequency vs consistency in social media with Northeast Kingdom Online
April 29, 2025
Struggling to balance how often you post on social media and maintaining a consistent presence? This article dives into the debate of frequency versus consistency in social media strategy, exploring how to find the perfect balance that maximizes engagement, builds trust, and keeps your audience coming back for more. Learn tips for crafting a posting schedule that works for you!
Show More