6 Email Marketing Mistakes to Avoid for Better Engagement

Email marketing can be an incredibly powerful tool but if not done properly it can actually negatively impact a business. It is important to create an execution plan when creating and implementing an email campaign. Below are some common mistakes to avoid when creating your email marketing plan.

Skipping proper email campaign planning and preparation

Proper planning and preparation for what awaits you and your future email audience is the first essential step that you have to take. First off, ask yourself some questions before moving on.

Here are a few questions you should ask yourself:


  • Can you really benefit from email marketing?
  • How will you engage your email list?
  • What type of content should you be sharing?
  • How often should you send these emails out without annoying your recipients?

Making a plan and deciding on the details of your email marketing strategy will help you clear up your vision, create relevant content, and ultimately help you reach your campaign goals.

Working with outdated mailing lists

Your email bounce rate and spam score are aspects that you need to be aware of. An email bounce simply means that your email isn’t going through to someone. Bounces happen for various reasons ranging from typos within an email address all the way to a recipient with a full inbox.

Email service providers pay close attention to your bounces and having a high bounce rate reflects poorly on your business. It is good practice to go through your email recipient list on a regular basis and remove any of these email addresses that are not going to the recipient.

Annoying your recipients with too many emails

Even through email marketing is a powerful tool, you do not want to send out so many email blasts that you are annoying your recipients. Be thoughtful in what you are sending out and make sure the email content is relevant to the recipient. This will help to lessen the chances of your recipients hitting the unsubscribe button.

Writing poor subject lines

The subject line within your email is a major factor when it comes to generating high open rates. Depending on how you’ve written the subject line, it will either catch the viewers attention or be completely ignored. There are several ways you can go about coming up with an impactful subject line, but ultimately you will need to see what works best for your email recipients. The best advice we can offer is to try new things, measure your open rate success and do more of what works.

Sending out a non-responsive email design

Today most internet users are using mobile devices when on the web, so it is incredibly important to make sure your email is setup for responsive design. If the recipient opens up an email on their phone that is only designed for a computer or tablet, the chances of this recipient opening another email from you will be drastically lower than if the email appears the best way possible on whatever device they are using.

Having an unclear call-to-action

Making sure you have a clear call to action is incredibly important when creating an email campaign. If there is no call to action, then what really is the point to send out the email? I am not only talking about the text included on buttons but also the text right before that, as well. A call-to-action button is effective only if it’s consistent with the text within the email.

Conclusion

Although email marketing can be a very effective tool, it needs to be executed properly. By avoiding these common mistakes listed above it will help you to fine tune your email campaigns and lead to a more successful marketing strategy.


If you would like some help with your email marketing, give Northeast Kingdom a call today at 802-473-1887 and we can help you to create a thoughtful and effective email campaign and strategy!

A bunch of red balloons with the word sale on them
By Blog Owner July 9, 2025
Boost your summer sale or pop-up with a promo page, countdown timer, event schema, and email support. Make your website part of the team!
A person is holding a cell phone with social media icons on the screen
By Blog Owner July 1, 2025
Discover what’s trending on social media in 2025. Plus, explore strategy sessions and content calendar services from Northeast Kingdom Online!
Canned spam emails with Northeast Kingdom Online
June 30, 2025
Learn how we know those "guest post services" emails are spam, how they can hurt your SEO, and what to do instead to build real website credibility.
A person holding up a phone in front of a TV, screensharing to the TV, showing social media posts.
June 24, 2025
Not sure how often to post on social media or your blog? This guide breaks down realistic, consistent content strategies for small business owners who want results—without the burnout.
Computer with abstract image of buildings, angled towards the sky, reading
June 17, 2025
Using a website theme? Learn how small businesses in Vermont can personalize it with custom colors, fonts, imagery, and messaging, so your site stands out, not blends in.
A laptop at a desk setting, with the LinkedIn logo on the screen.
June 10, 2025
LinkedIn isn’t just for job seekers. Discover how Vermont small businesses and service providers can use it to build trust, grow local networks, and share their expertise effectively.
A red, neon, 404 sign, signifying an error.
June 4, 2025
Not sure if your website is still working for your business? Discover 6 common signs it's time for a redesign, like outdated visuals, slow speed, or unclear messaging, and what to do next.
A wall that is covered with sticky notes is a disorganized mess.
May 21, 2025
Dreaming of viral content and sleek branding? The real secret to a strong digital presence starts with a content calendar. Discover how strategic planning, consistency, and simple content themes can transform your online strategy—no stress spirals required.
Two women sitting together on a couch, smiling about the content they are looking at on a laptop.
May 21, 2025
Not getting the engagement you hoped for on social media? You’re not alone—and the good news is, it’s fixable. In this post, we unpack the most common reasons your content might be falling flat (think: unclear messaging, inconsistent posting, or missing calls to action) and share practical, easy-to-implement fixes. Whether you're DIYing your digital marketing or leading a small team, this guide will help you turn silent posts into strategic conversations that actually click.
Letter tiles spelling out the word, blog, on a desk.
May 21, 2025
Wondering if blogging is still worth it? Spoiler: it is. In this post, we break down exactly why blogging remains a powerful tool for growing your business—boosting visibility, building trust, and supporting your entire content strategy. You’ll also get simple blog topic ideas to help you get started with ease.
Show More